Blog
Céline Dostaler
Tougher Sentences for Sexual Assault in Ontario: Why You Need a Strong Criminal Defence
In recent years, sentencing for sexual assault in Ontario has become significantly harsher. Courts are imposing longer jail terms, and house arrest (conditional sentences) is becoming increasingly rare. These changes reflect a broader push for stricter penalties, with judges prioritizing deterrence and denunciation over rehabilitation.
For individuals accused of sexual assault, this trend underscores the critical importance of a strong legal defence. A well-planned defence strategy can help fight the charges before conviction, and if convicted, a skilled criminal defence lawyer can argue for a lighter sentence.
This article explores the changing sentencing landscape for sexual assault in Ontario, the key legal defences available, and the role of a criminal defence lawyer in protecting the rights of the accused.
Why Sexual Assault Sentencing in Ontario is Becoming Harsher
Sexual assault is taken very seriously in Canadian courts, and in recent years, sentencing has become more severe. Several factors contribute to this trend:
1. Stricter Laws and Policy Changes
The Canadian Criminal Code has been amended to limit judicial discretion in sentencing certain offences, including sexual assault. The courts now have fewer options for alternative sentences such as house arrest.
In particular, Bill C-5, which came into effect in 2022, removed the availability of conditional sentences for certain sexual offences. This means that many individuals convicted of sexual assault must now serve time in jail rather than serving their sentence in the community.
2. Increased Focus on Victim Rights and Public Pressure
High-profile sexual assault cases, along with movements like #MeToo, have led to greater awareness of sexual violence. As a result, there is significant pressure on the courts to impose harsher penalties to reflect the seriousness of the crime.
3. Judicial Sentencing Trends
Judges in Ontario are increasingly emphasizing deterrence and denunciation in sentencing. This means they are focusing on punishing offenders and discouraging others from committing similar crimes, rather than prioritizing rehabilitation.
According to a Statistics Canada report, 50% of sexual assault convictions between 2015 and 2019 resulted in jail time, with an increasing trend toward longer sentences.
4. Reduced Availability of House Arrest
House arrest, or conditional sentencing, was previously an option for some sexual assault cases, particularly when there were mitigating factors. However, recent legal changes and judicial attitudes have made this much less common. Now, even first-time offenders are more likely to face significant jail time rather than being allowed to serve their sentence at home.
Fighting Sexual Assault Charges Before Conviction
Given the increased severity of sentencing, it is critical for individuals accused of sexual assault to build a strong defence before conviction. A criminal defence lawyer plays a vital role in challenging the prosecution’s case and ensuring that the accused receives a fair trial.
Key Defence Strategies:
1. Challenging the Credibility of the Complainant
Many sexual assault cases rely heavily on witness testimony rather than physical evidence. A defence lawyer can cross-examine the complainant to identify inconsistencies, contradictions, or biases in their statements.
2. Lack of Evidence
In criminal cases, the prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. If there is insufficient or weak evidence, the defence can argue for a dismissal of the charges.
3. Consent Defence
Consent is a key issue in sexual assault cases. If there is evidence that the complainant consented to the act, the defence may argue that the accused reasonably believed consent was given.
4. Mistaken Identity or False Accusations
Some sexual assault cases involve mistaken identity or false accusations due to personal disputes or other motives. A defence lawyer can present evidence that supports an alibi or disproves the allegations.
5. Charter Violations
If law enforcement violated the accused’s rights during the investigation, such as conducting an unlawful search or failing to provide legal counsel, the defence may argue for the exclusion of evidence.
6. Mental State and Intent
In some cases, the defence may argue that the accused did not have the required intent to commit a crime, which could lead to lesser charges or an acquittal.
A strong defence before conviction can lead to dropped charges, an acquittal, or a plea deal for lesser offences.
Reducing Sentences After Conviction
If an individual is convicted of sexual assault, a criminal defence lawyer still plays a crucial role in reducing the severity of the sentence.
Key Sentencing Factors Considered by the Court:
1. Aggravating Factors (Increase Sentence)
- Use of violence, threats, or a weapon
- Prior criminal record, especially for sexual offences
- Abuse of a position of trust (e.g., teacher, coach, doctor)
- Multiple victims or repeated offences
2. Mitigating Factors (Reduce Sentence)
- No prior criminal history
- Genuine remorse and willingness to undergo rehabilitation
- Voluntary participation in counselling or treatment programs
- Cooperation with authorities
How a Defence Lawyer Can Reduce Sentencing:
1. Negotiating a Plea Bargain
In some cases, a lawyer can negotiate a plea deal with the prosecution to have the charges reduced to a lesser offence, which carries a lighter sentence.
2. Arguing for a Lesser Sentence
A defence lawyer can present mitigating factors to persuade the judge to impose a shorter jail term or an alternative sentence such as probation.
3. Presenting Character Evidence
Submitting letters from family, employers, or community members that attest to the accused’s character and contributions to society can help reduce sentencing.
4. Requesting Alternative Sentencing (If Available)
Although conditional sentences (house arrest) are less common, a lawyer may still argue for other alternatives, such as probation, if the circumstances allow.
5. Appealing the Sentence
If the sentence is excessively harsh, a lawyer may file an appeal to seek a reduction.
Why Hiring a Criminal Defence Lawyer is Critical
With the growing severity of sexual assault sentencing in Ontario, it is crucial for anyone facing these charges to hire an experienced criminal defence lawyer.
What a Defence Lawyer Can Do:
- Provide Legal Guidance: Explain your rights and legal options
- Develop a Defence Strategy: Build a strong case to fight the charges
- Challenge the Prosecution’s Evidence: Identify weaknesses in the case against you
- Represent You in Court: Advocate for you during trials and sentencing hearings
- Negotiate Sentencing Options: Work to reduce penalties if convicted
Without a skilled lawyer, the risk of a lengthy prison sentence is significantly higher.
Protect Your Rights and Future
Ontario courts are imposing increasingly harsh sentences for sexual assault, with longer jail terms and fewer opportunities for house arrest. If you are facing these charges, the importance of a strong defence cannot be overstated. A criminal defence lawyer can help fight the charges before conviction and work to reduce sentencing if convicted.
If you or someone you know is facing sexual assault charges in Ottawa, you need experienced legal representation. Contact Celine today to discuss your case and protect your rights.
